![]() |
Cases in Point
Home
Elaine Mosher, PhD |
Artificial Insemination......and other contemporary lifestyle choices
When Louise's daughter Jane got a divorce from her perfectly nice
husband, Louise felt deeply sad and disappointed, but was eventually
consolable.
"That's life in these times", she conceded.
A year later, when Jane announced that she was coming out of the
closet as a lesbian, Louise was more than upset and bewildered. On
the other hand, that certainly explained the divorce...
The upside of all this was that Jane had a marvelous career as an
attorney and by now had found an admirable same-sex partner. Clearly,
Louise is still reeling from the emotional turmoil, and it will be
some time until she can gives up blaming herself.
Letting go of prejudices is an act of will. But when Jane decided on
artificial insemination in order to become a mother, Louise went
numb. What could one say to a woman married in the 50's and plunged
into the 90's by reason of time and change?
"At least, Jane has a partner," I heard myself say.
"A committed life partner to share the parenting and the life-
that's a lot to be thankful for these days."
What about the single woman, with no partner in her life who opts
out for insemination because she is afraid to miss out on motherhood?
She may simply have a deep and abiding need to have a child.
"It's my life," she says, "I'll decide what my priorities are. I
want a child to love and raise and I can have one now. I can afford
it. Then, if I find a man to join me in my life, that will be great;
and if not, I don't lose out on motherhood."
Relationships in our society are not stable. Marriage is a fragile
institution at best. For some, the dad who was your husband is often
long gone - or you may wish he were. The deadbeat dad is another
blight on the family. Some women, particularly those with financial
security, seem determined to bypass dependence on finding or keeping
a relationship in order to make a family -albeit a single parent one.
Artificial insemination talks to women's autonomy and independence.
But it also reflects a deep disappointment and distrust.
The issue of the fatherless family is distressing. The implication
that fathers are useless - or a nuisance at worst - does not alter
the fact that they are the balance to the mother role and a source of
male energy that provides stability and strength.
In spite of the failure of many men in their role as father, however
badly played, the role remains one of tremendous importance in
numerous ways, not least of which involves sexual and gender identity.
The balance of a mother and a father as a model of the love between
man and woman may be only an ideal in our times, experienced by the
fortunate; but that ideal has defined the basic unit of society. We
are witnessing the changing forms and structure of the family and its
gathering variations.
Questions arise about the consciousness of the unborn child,
conceived sans human connection. Will these children be different
from the start, at a core level?
One has to wonder whether the choice of artificial insemination,
over adoption, resides in an anger toward men and fathers,
attempting to render them irrelevant, passé, a vestige of an
earlier time.
What does this say about how men and women in our time feel about
each other? Is this an ultimate feminist solution to a sexist society?
Elaine Z Mosher PhD
Cases in Point: Archive
Home || Contact
|
![]()
Site contents © 1999
E&F MosherSite Design:
John Blower/FeNiKs